
Welcome to Ultraground. We bring together fragmented data for real estate development.
This report sets INLIVIAN's four joint ventures with private developers side by side: who holds the seat, what share of the developer fee, cash flow and sale proceeds INLIVIAN's development company takes, who guarantees, and what INLIVIAN brings in land and vouchers. Alleghany Crossing leads, followed by Trella Uptown, The Vue at Honeywood and Evoke Living at Ballantyne. Read Online, at the top right, opens the full report in a browser. The email captures each deal as of November 5, 2026; the project page linked from each section stays current.
Deal Tracker November 5, 2026 – CC October 9, 2023 – CC November 21, 2022 – CC October 17, 2022
District: 2 | West Inner
220-Unit Multifamily | 1014 Alleghany Park Way | Under Construction
Deal Tracker November 5, 2026 – CC September 22, 2025 – INLIVIAN September 16, 2025 – CC November 28, 2022 – LGC October 4, 2022 – INLIVIAN September 20, 2022 – CC December 13, 2021 – CC September 27, 2021 – INLIVIAN April 20, 2021
District: 1 | Uptown
353-Unit Mixed-Use | 426 N Tryon St | Built
Deal Tracker November 5, 2026 – LGC September 9, 2025 – CC March 24, 2025 – CC January 21, 2025 – ZC January 7, 2025 – CC December 16, 2024 – CC April 24, 2023
District: 2 | West Inner
108-Unit Multifamily | 545 Honeywood Ave | Under Construction
Deal Tracker November 5, 2026 – CC June 24, 2024 – CC February 26, 2024 – CC April 24, 2023 – CC November 15, 2021
District: 7 | South Outer
60-Unit Multifamily | 10615 and 10701 Dixie Hills Dr | Built
INLIVIAN Joint Venture Terms
Term | Alleghany Crossing | Trella Uptown | The Vue at Honeywood | Evoke Living at Ballantyne |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Private developer | Elmington Capital Group | Urban Atlantic | Trinity Housing Development | Freedom Communities and Crosland Southeast |
Units, status | 220, under construction | 353 (106 affordable), built | 108, under construction | 60, built |
Agreement date | 1/23/23 | 12/1/22 | 5/16/25, amended 8/28/25 | 3/15/23 |
INLIVIAN's seat | Sole general partner, 0.003% | 51% of the affordable side's managing member | Managing member, 0.0051% | 15% of the managing member, member only |
Developer fee | $4,400,000 | $1,431,000 | $1,960,000 | $1,200,000 |
INLIVIAN's fee share | 30% (Elmington 70%) | 75% (Urban Atlantic 25%) | 30% (Trinity 70%) | 15% (Crosland 80%, Freedom 5%) |
Net cash flow | Elmington 63%, INLIVIAN 27%, Truist 10% | Managing member 90% as incentive fee, investors 10% | Investor 10%; the 90% split Trinity 80%, INLIVIAN 20% | Truist 10%; the managing member's balance split Freedom 70%, INLIVIAN 15%, Crosland 15% |
Sale proceeds | Elmington 63%, INLIVIAN 27%, Truist 10% | Managing member 90%, investors 10% | Trinity 72%, INLIVIAN 18%, investor 10% | Managing member 90%, Truist 10% |
Guaranties | Elmington; none required of INLIVIAN | Urban Atlantic; none from INLIVIAN | Trinity, all; none from INLIVIAN | Crosland's CSE Communities, all |
Tax credit price | $0.95, Truist Community Capital | $0.90, Red Stone Equity | $0.90, Raymond James | $0.94, Truist Community Capital |
Vouchers | 55 | HAP contract on 69 units | 27 | 12, planned as leased by year end |
Land | Bought by the partnership for $4,120,000 | INLIVIAN's, 99-year ground lease, $50,000 base rent from cash flow, up 3% a year | Held in fee, no ground lease; $1,790,000 | City's, 75-year ground lease at $1 a year |
Issuer fee | $212,500 plus 0.125% a year | $219,375 plus 0.125% a year |
In all four, the private developer gives the guaranties, and INLIVIAN's development company, Horizon Development Properties (HDP), is paid for what it brings: the land at Trella, a general partner seat meant to qualify Alleghany for the property tax exemption and 55 vouchers there, 12 vouchers at Evoke, and the managing member seat and 27 vouchers at The Vue. At Trella INLIVIAN's money is also in the building: INLIVIAN's $4,361,191 loan in the December 2025 sources, and the $3,000,000 completion loan from the managing member INLIVIAN owns 51% of.
Evoke's March 2023 agreement gave an INLIVIAN subsidiary 15% of the managing member, member only, and 15% of the fee for 12 vouchers; Alleghany's January 2023 agreement made INLIVIAN sole general partner at 30% of the fee and 27% of cash flow and sale proceeds. The Vue's May 2025 agreement prices the seat in more pieces: 30% of the fee, 20% of the partners' 90% of cash flow, 18% of the sale balance, options and a right of refusal after the compliance period, and consent over the operating agreement, contractors, lenders, investors and plans. Trella's signed pre-closing outline split the fee 50/50; the closed deal gave INLIVIAN 75% of the fee, and INLIVIAN kept the land.
JPI Real-Time Tracking Link: INLIVIAN Deals


DISTRICT: 2

Alleghany Crossing Apartments 1014 Alleghany Park Way
West Inner | 11.96 Acres | 220 Units | Under Construction
Deal Tracker 11/5/26 – City Council 10/9/23
Up to $40,000,000 INLIVIAN Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds, Section 147(f) | Approved
Elmington Capital Group, the Nashville developer, is building Alleghany Crossing's 220 apartments with INLIVIAN inside the partnership. C. Hunter Nelson, an Elmington partner, signed the joint venture as its Secretary on January 18, 2023, and it took effect January 23; Senior Vice President of Development Joseph Horowitz came from Nashville for the rezoning hearing. INLIVIAN's development company, Horizon Development Properties (HDP), holds the sole general partner seat, 0.003% beside the investor's 99.99%, and co-develops; Fulton Meachem signed for both, as INLIVIAN's President and CEO and HDP's President. Elmington leads and takes 70% of the developer fee, cash flow, and sale or refinance proceeds; INLIVIAN takes 30%. INLIVIAN commits 55 project-based vouchers to the 30% AMI units, and the joint venture ends automatically if they are never allocated.
Charlotte City Council approved INLIVIAN's issuance of up to $40,000,000 of multifamily housing revenue bonds for the partnership, HDP Alleghany, LP, on its consent agenda on October 9, 2023; no one had spoken at INLIVIAN's September 7 hearing. The State's Local Government Commission cleared the $40,000,000 issue on November 14, 2023, the same day it cleared $21,000,000 for INLIVIAN's Fairhaven Glen. Mecklenburg County issued building permits for all five buildings on April 19, 2024.
INLIVIAN'S JV TERMS
Term | Elmington | INLIVIAN | Truist |
|---|---|---|---|
Partnership seat | Class B partner, 0.007% | Sole general partner, 0.003% | Investor, 99.99% |
Developer fee, $4,400,000 | 70%, $3,080,000 | 30%, $1,320,000 | |
Residual cash flow | 63% | 27% | 10% |
Sale or refinance proceeds | 63% | 27% | 10% |
Guaranties and predevelopment | All | None | |
Vouchers | 55 project-based | ||
Exit after year 15 | Right of first refusal; options on the investor's interest and the project |

Deal Tracker
Site work ran well ahead of the buildings. The City issued the grading permit on June 18, 2024, and the County passed the first foundation inspection on December 10, 2024, but the City's grading inspector wrote on October 7, 2025 that the site "has not begun building construction due to Charlotte Water requirements"; by December 10 vertical construction had begun.
The City approved revised construction plans on January 9 and October 19, 2026. The City's grading inspector found some hardscaping and landscaping work on October 29, 2026, and the five-sign permit filed that day went back on November 2 because each sign needs its own. The County's latest inspection, on November 5, 2026, partly approved the frame recheck and insulation at Building A2's fitness center; no building has a final inspection or certificate of occupancy.

U/ Finance
Truist Community Capital's March 2023 terms price the equity at $0.95 per dollar of credits, on $3,252,896 a year of 4% housing credits and $2,500 a unit of 45L energy credits. Truist Bank would lend up to $52,859,018 for construction at one-month SOFR plus 2.50%, and Grandbridge would take out $32,408,235 at 5.25%, a 15-year term on 40-year amortization. The budget comes to $72,778,919, $330,813 a unit, with a $4,400,000 developer fee, $2,045,671 of it deferred.
FROM $49M TO $40M OF BONDS
In May 2023, Elmington and INLIVIAN sought $49,000,000 of bond volume, with the bank loan split into two 5.25% tranches. The second tranche, $6,903,091 with $413,250 of annual debt service, rested on $526,812 a year of voucher subsidy above the tax credit rents:
‟Utilizing the PBV rental subsidy as a funding source is necessary to offset the additional costs associated with using Davis Bacon wage rates triggered by the PBVs, among other costs.
Elmington and INLIVIAN then replaced that second tranche with a $6,903,091 member loan at 3.43% and no scheduled debt service, took the voucher subsidy out of projected income and cut the bond request to $40,000,000, the amount Council approved. The bank loan alone carries $1,940,101 of annual debt service at 1.151 coverage.
WHO CARRIES THE RISK
Elmington Construction builds, an Elmington affiliate holds the Class B limited partner interest, and Elmington arranges every completion, repayment, tax credit, and operating deficit guaranty and funds all predevelopment, reimbursed at the initial closing. INLIVIAN has no obligation to fund operating deficits, capital contributions, partner loans, repurchase obligations or guaranties, never refunds predevelopment costs, and gives a guaranty only in a form and scope it accepts. Elmington Affordable and five individual partners of the Class B partner, Scott Sohr, Ben Brewer, Cary Rosenblum, Hunter Nelson and Ryan Seibels, guarantee the Class B partner's, developer's and general partner's obligations with $2,000,000 of liquidity and $5,000,000 of net worth; the personal guaranties burn off at stabilization and 8609s. The Class B partner funds operating deficits, capped at $3,270,448 after the stabilization installment, until the end of that installment's fifth anniversary year if coverage averages 1.15 and the reserves are whole.
INLIVIAN's control as general partner is meant to qualify the project for North Carolina's property tax exemption, which INLIVIAN agreed is critical to the financing. Residual cash flow and sale or refinancing proceeds split the same way: 10% to Truist under its draft, and the balance 70% to Elmington and 30% to INLIVIAN under the joint venture, or 63%, 27%, and 10%. After the 15-year compliance period, the general partner holds a one-year first option to buy the property, at the greater of fair market value or the debt and amounts owed, and a right of first refusal at the debt plus the sale's income taxes. The joint venture reserves the right of first refusal at the Section 42(i)(7) price and the options to buy the investor's interest and the project for INLIVIAN alone.
COST AND LAND
Construction, site work, design and engineering total $51,427,940, $233,763 a unit, $32,780,000 of it for the buildings; Mecklenburg County valued the five building permits at $24,130,195. Elmington Construction builds as an identity-of-interest contractor, with $2,521,200 of profit in the budget. The budget carries the land at its $4,200,000 option price; HDP Alleghany took title on February 28, 2024, for $4,120,000.


City Council 11/21/22
2022-055: B-D(CD), INST, R-17MF → R-22MF(CD) | Approved
Council approved the rezoning 8 to 1 on November 21, 2022, on Council Member Tariq Bokhari's motion and the second of Council Member Malcolm Graham, whose District 2 holds the site; Council Members Reneé Johnson and Victoria Watlington were absent. Council adopted it as inconsistent with the 2040 Policy Map, which called for Commercial, and moved the site to the Neighborhood 2 place type. LaWana Mayfield, At Large, pulled it from the consent group for a separate vote, said the area had changed tremendously since she represented it, and voted no:

‟I would like us to get an update and have a different conversation regarding moving forward with how we're looking at industrial institutional land and what multifamily could look like. So I will be a no, but I know my colleagues will be in support of.
The Zoning Committee had recommended approval 5-0 on November 1. Chair Phillip Gussman backed the connections the petition makes to the surrounding streets; Melissa Gaston asked about the height of the single-family attached homes and whether housing already stood along Bullard St, and Douglas Welton asked whether a buffer would separate the site from the properties across Granger Ave. Between the hearing and the vote, Elmington widened the trail easement from Camp Greene Park to Alleghany St from 10 feet to 80 feet, after Mecklenburg County asked for at least 100.

City Council 10/17/22
2022-055: B-D(CD), INST, R-17MF → R-22MF(CD) | Hearing Held
Staff recommended approval of up to 220 apartments capped at 65 feet and five single family attached homes capped at 50 feet, once site and building design issues were resolved; no one signed up to speak against the rezoning. Collin Brown of Alexander Ricks, for Elmington, said the plan builds out the area's street network: it extends Granger Ave and Liggett St to public street standards and adds an 8-foot buffered bike lane on Alleghany St. Council Member Victoria Watlington, District 3, turned the hearing to tree loss:

‟I'm sure glad you showed this because I was wondering where the trees were going.
She asked whether the City tracks tree losses from each month's rezonings and requested a follow-up on tree acreage loss; Planning's David Pettine said losses are hard to gauge before final permitting. Council Member Danté Anderson, District 1, pointed to Tree Charlotte's annual canopy assessments, and Council Member Reneé Johnson, District 4, asked for visual aids showing traffic and approved rezonings in Council's zoning books:

‟Once a month I feel like we have to kind of ignore our priorities and focus on the growth of the city.
Read the Full Analysis: 11/5/26 – 10/17/22 Alleghany Crossing
Developer: Elmington Capital Group
C. Hunter Nelson (Partner) Phone: (615) 490-6711 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Joseph Horowitz (Senior Vice President of Development) Phone: (615) 490-6709 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Public Partner: INLIVIAN
Heather Franklin (Interim President and CEO) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Mo McRae (Chief Development Officer) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Capital Partners:
Truist Community Capital (Tax Credit Investor), Brian Womble (Senior Vice President, Relationship Manager) Phone: (404) 588-8775 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Truist Bank (Construction Lender)
Grandbridge Real Estate Capital (Permanent Lender)
Representatives:
Elmington Construction (General Contractor), Cochrane Jamison (President of Construction and Development Services) Phone: (629) 800-5463 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
SV Design (Architect), Samantha O'Leary (Partner) Phone: (629) 257-6770 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Alexander Ricks (Attorney), Collin Brown (Member) Phone: (704) 365-3656 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn, Brittany Lins (Member) Phone: (704) 365-3656 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Reno & Cavanaugh (Attorney), Dwayne Barrett (Member) Phone: (615) 866-3224 Email: [email protected]
Staff Report: 2022-055, 2022-055 Pre-Hearing Analysis
Project Plans: Alleghany Crossing Apartments Plans, 2022-055 Rezoning Plan (November 21, 2022), 2022-055 Rezoning Plan (October 17, 2022)
Ordinance: 2022-055 Ordinance
Pro Forma: Alleghany Crossing Operating Pro Forma (October 29, 2024), Alleghany Crossing Operating Pro Forma (August 3, 2023)
Term Sheet: Alleghany Crossing Member Loan Term Sheet (August 1, 2023), Alleghany Crossing Permanent Loan Term Sheet (May 10, 2023), Truist Community Capital Term Sheet (March 22, 2023)
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU): Alleghany Crossing Joint Venture Agreement (January 23, 2023)
Closing Documents: Alleghany Crossing Ownership Chart
Deal Scan: Alleghany Crossing Apartments Deal Scan


DISTRICT: 1

Trella Uptown 426 N Tryon St
Uptown | 2.2 Acres | 353 Units | Built
Deal Tracker 11/5/26 – City Council 9/22/25
Up to $3,000,000 in INLIVIAN Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds | Approved
INLIVIAN keeps the land under Trella Uptown. Its development company, Horizon Development Properties (HDP), owns the block at N Tryon St and E 8th St, and on December 23, 2022, ground-leased it for 99 years to two companies that split one seven-story building between them. 8th and Tryon AUOE, LLC holds the 106 affordable units, financed with INLIVIAN's tax-exempt bonds and 4% tax credits; 8th and Tryon MROE, LLC holds the 247 market-rate units, financed on its own. INLIVIAN owns 51% of the affordable side's managing member, and Urban Atlantic, led by managing partners Lois Fried and Vicki Davis, owns 49%. INLIVIAN keeps 75% of the $1,431,000 developer fee, up from the 50% the two had set in the signed outline that preceded closing, and took a $212,500 bond issuance fee at closing.
INLIVIAN's board approved a further issuance of up to $3,000,000 for the same borrower on September 16, 2025, for financing or refinancing, after a public hearing on August 11 at which no one spoke. Charlotte City Council approved it on September 22 on its consent agenda.
INLIVIAN'S JV TERMS
Term | INLIVIAN | Urban Atlantic |
|---|---|---|
Managing member, affordable side | 51% | 49% |
Developer fee, $1,431,000 | 75%, $1,073,250 | 25%, $357,750 |
Land | Owns it; 99-year ground lease to 12/31/2121 | |
Ground rent | $50,000 for fiscal 2025, up 3% a year; net cash flow only for 39 years | |
Bond issuer fees | $212,500 at closing, 0.125% a year | |
Guaranties | None | Completion, tax credits, deficits to $795,000, $1,000,000 more if the HAP is cut |
End of lease | Affordable building reverts at no cost |

Deal Tracker
Trella Uptown is built. Mecklenburg County issued the building's permits section by section between May 25, 2023, starting with the footings, and September 11, 2024, and closed the final one on June 23, 2026; the City finaled the grading permit on July 9, 2026. The County issued certificates of occupancy across the project from December 9, 2025 to June 23, 2026, every residential level among them. Its newest inspection, an electrical final on Shell Section C, passed on August 20, 2026; that section still shows no certificate, with five holds open from City Fire, Commercial Zoning, Urban Forestry and Charlotte Water. The City's landscape inspector failed the streetscape on April 16, 2026 for the wrong tree species on 8th and College and an unscreened transformer, and finalized it on May 20.

U/ Finance
INLIVIAN priced $16,348,000 of Series 2022 bonds on December 20, 2022, rated Aaa/VMIG 1, at a 5.00% initial rate and 103.982% of par, and delivered them on December 23. Through construction, the bonds rested on cash, not on the building: draws on JPMorgan Chase's $16,287,972 construction loan and the INLIVIAN and City loans served as collateral, and June 1, 2026 was the bonds' first mandatory tender date. Massachusetts Mutual Life, through Barings, takes out up to $13,798,419 as the permanent lender.
RAIN EVENT AND THE DECEMBER 2025 BUDGET
After the January 2024 rain event, the budget stood at $43,941,472 in December 2025, $414,542 a unit, up from $33,965,921 at closing. The managing member, 8T Affordable Partners, LLC, lent $3,000,000 to cover the overruns, unsecured and subordinate and repaid first from insurance proceeds; the August 27, 2025 amendment raised that loan from $1,300,000. $910,714 of the developer fee is now deferred, and the operating reserve is $795,000. MassMutual's $13,798,419 permanent loan and Red Stone's $15,142,231 of equity lead the December 2025 sources, beside INLIVIAN's $4,361,191 loan at 4.34% on a 20-year term and 30-year amortization, the City's $3,200,000, the completion loan and the deferred fee.
WHO CARRIES THE RISK
Urban Atlantic, not INLIVIAN, is the guarantor: it backs construction completion and the tax credits, and operating deficit loans up to $795,000 for at least five years after stabilized operations, plus up to $1,000,000 more if the HAP contract is cut. Once those guaranties release Urban Atlantic, INLIVIAN may take over asset management and its $35,000 annual fee, indexed to CPI, which is paid only after the market-rate side is sold and is capped at the incentive management fee the managing member receives. At closing, INLIVIAN's $7,800,000 Loan A carried 4.00% through conversion and its $6,000,000 Loan B, funded by a Mecklenburg County grant, 4.34% over 240 months. As long as an INLIVIAN entity stays in the managing member, INLIVIAN, as lender of the County money, will not foreclose, accelerate, or join a bankruptcy during the compliance period. The City's $3,200,000 Housing Trust Fund loan is a 1% second lien paid from cash flow.
INLIVIAN'S RETURN: THE GROUND LEASE
INLIVIAN earns its return through lease cash. The signed outline had priced ground rent at 3% of the land's appraised value, escalating 1.5% a year and paid quarterly from stabilization; the lease set base rent at $50,000 for fiscal 2025, first due June 1, 2026, and rises 3% a year; for 39 years it is paid only from net cash flow, and unpaid rent accrues at 4.32% until it all comes due in the 40th year. When the lease ends on December 31, 2121, the affordable building becomes INLIVIAN's at no cost. Fulton Meachem signed on both sides of the table: as INLIVIAN's CEO on the bond Regulatory Agreement and as HDP's President on the Ground Lease and the Development Agreement.
Land Control: Two Owners in One Building
INLIVIAN keeps the land; the affordable company leases its share of the building and owns the improvements for the term. Its 106 units are described level by level by elevation, from Level 0 through Level 7, inside one building. NRP Construction built the whole building under a $79,861,717 guaranteed maximum price, 30% of it charged to the affordable side, and the two owners share one fire pump, one domestic water loop, stormwater and trash. After the tax credit compliance period, the affordable company has a right of first refusal if INLIVIAN takes a third-party offer for 51% or more of its land.

Read the Full Analysis: 11/5/26 – 4/20/21 Trella Uptown
Developer: Urban Atlantic
Lois Fried (Managing Partner) Phone: (301) 280-6600 Email: [email protected]
Vicki Davis (Managing Partner) Phone: (301) 280-6600 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Public Partner: INLIVIAN
Heather Franklin (Interim President and CEO) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Mo McRae (Chief Development Officer) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Capital Partners:
JPMorgan Chase (Construction Lender)
Barings for Massachusetts Mutual Life (Permanent Lender), Daron Tubian (Managing Director, Head of Affordable Housing Investments) Phone: (212) 878-6050 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Red Stone Equity Partners (Tax Credit Investor), Robert U. Fein (Principal and Chief Operating Officer) Phone: (216) 820-4760 Email: [email protected]
City of Charlotte (Housing Trust Fund Loan)
Mecklenburg County (Grant behind INLIVIAN Loan B)
Representatives:
The NRP Group (General Contractor), Dan Brenner (Executive Vice President of Project Operations) Phone: (844) 677-0002 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
LaBella Associates (Architect), Brad Bartholomew (National Design Director) Phone: (646) 319-6685 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Kimley-Horn (Civil Engineer), Matthew Edwards (Vice President) Phone: (704) 333-5131 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Fox Rothschild (Attorney), Michael H. Syme (Office Managing Partner) Phone: (412) 391-2450 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Saul Ewing (Attorney), Jeffrey Gelman (Partner) Phone: (202) 295-6647 Email: [email protected]
The Banks Law Firm (INLIVIAN's Counsel), Sherrod Banks (Shareholder) Phone: (919) 474-9137 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Applegate & Thorne-Thomsen (Attorney), Bennett P. Applegate (Attorney) Phone: (312) 491-3322 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Staff Report: Trella Uptown
Project Plans: Trella Uptown Plans
Presentation: Trella Uptown Housing Trust Fund
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU): Trella Uptown Amended and Restated Transaction Outline
Ground Lease: Trella Uptown Ground Lease
Development Agreement: Trella Uptown Development Agreement
Operating Agreement: 8th and Tryon AUOE Operating Agreement
Regulatory Agreement: INLIVIAN Regulatory Agreement, City Declaration of Deed Restrictions
Term Sheet: City Housing Trust Fund Commitment Letter
Pro Forma: Trella Uptown Pro Forma
Closing Documents: Trella Uptown Completion Loan Amendment (August 27, 2025), Trella Uptown Official Statement (December 20, 2022)
Deal Scan: Trella Uptown Deal Scan


DISTRICT: 2

The Vue at Honeywood 545 Honeywood Ave
West Inner | 6.95 Acres | 108 Units | Under Construction
Deal Tracker 11/5/26 – North Carolina Local Government Commission 9/9/25
Up to $18,000,000 INLIVIAN Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds | Approved
Trinity Housing Development, the Springfield, Missouri, tax-credit developer led by Ryan Hamilton, is building its first Charlotte project with INLIVIAN on the inside. INLIVIAN's development company, Horizon Development Properties (HDP), holds the managing member seat of the borrower through HDP Honeywood, LLC, with a 0.0051% interest, and co-develops with Trinity under a Development Agreement dated February 1, 2026. Under the Joint Venture Agreement, the two signed on May 16, 2025, INLIVIAN takes 30% of the development fee and Trinity 70%, paid pari passu. Net cash flow, after the investor's items, reserves, the unpaid fee, the subordinate loans, Trinity's guaranty repayments and incentive fee, and both partners' asset management fees, goes 10% to the investor member and 90% to Trinity and INLIVIAN, split 80% to Trinity and 20% to INLIVIAN; the sale proceeds balance goes 18% to INLIVIAN, 72% to Trinity, and 10% to the investor member. INLIVIAN provides no guarantees: Trinity gives all of them and funds predevelopment, reimbursed at equity syndication. INLIVIAN also takes its return as issuer: $219,375 at closing and 0.125% a year on the bonds outstanding. The North Carolina Local Government Commission approved up to $18,000,000 of INLIVIAN bonds on September 9, 2025; the $17,550,000 issue closed on February 25, 2026; all three apartment buildings now hold building permits, and site work is underway.

Deal Tracker
Work has started on the site, with no foundation inspection yet as of November 5. The City's inspector found storm drain and sewer line installation in progress on August 12, 2026, and the County passed the sewer service inspection on October 21 after five partial approvals in September. The County issued building permits for all three buildings on April 1 and 2, 2026, with Wynnefield Contracting Services as the contractor. The site came first: the City approved the construction plan on July 18, 2025, 21 months and five review rounds after the plans went in; the County issued the site works permit on March 18, 2026, a retaining wall permit on March 30, the sewer and water permit on May 13, and two more walls on August 14. The clubhouse permit, dated April 13, 2026, has expired, along with the mechanical, electrical, and plumbing permits under all three buildings. Raymond James projected its second equity installment, $2,977,997, for October 2026 at 65% completion.

U/ Finance
The bonds are unrated and were sold through Piper Sandler. Fifth Third Bank's $23,500,000 construction loan sits ahead of the bonds until the property stabilizes and is due August 1, 2028, with a six-month extension option, the same date the bonds' stabilization deadline falls. The Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta has also awarded $1,125,000 in Affordable Housing Program funds, with the bonds expected to close within 120 days.
SIX STEPS FROM $12.5M TO $17.55M
INLIVIAN raised its ceiling from $12.5 million in 2022 to $17 million in 2023 and $18 million in 2025, and Council approved the plan of financing twice, at two amounts.
Date | Action | Amount |
|---|---|---|
4/19/22 | INLIVIAN preliminary resolution | Up to $12,500,000 |
3/21/23 | INLIVIAN amends; the borrower plans a $17,000,000 volume cap application to NCHFA | Up to $17,000,000 |
6/24/24 | City Council approval of the plan of financing | Up to $14,600,000 |
3/24/25 | City Council approval again, unanimous | Up to $17,000,000 |
8/19/25 | INLIVIAN Resolutions 2703 and 2704, unanimous | Up to $18,000,000, $1,000,000 of it taxable |
2/25/26 | Bonds closed | $17,550,000, $550,000 of it taxable |
INLIVIAN's board heard in 2023 that "the amount of tax-exempt debt needed to finance the cost of the Development is more than originally anticipated." The $17,000,000 of tax-exempt bonds in the offering matches the 2023 volume cap plan to the dollar.
INLIVIAN'S JV TERMS
Term | Trinity | INLIVIAN | Investor Member |
|---|---|---|---|
Development fee | 70% | 30% | |
Net cash flow | 80% of the 90% | 20% of the 90% | 10% |
Sale proceeds balance | 72% | 18% | 10% |
Guaranties and predevelopment | All | None |
INLIVIAN also holds the exits and the approvals. After the 15-year compliance period, it holds options to buy the investor's and Trinity's interests, or the project, for the outstanding debts plus the investor's tax liability and unpaid adjuster payments, and a Section 42(i)(7) right of refusal, and the reserves stay with the project if it buys. It approves or consents to the owner's operating agreement, service providers, contractors, lenders, investors, the voucher contracts, and the plans. Net construction cost savings pay the deferred fee to Trinity and INLIVIAN pari passu, then member loans and project debt, then a supportive services escrow for INLIVIAN's programs. The agreement set December 31, 2025 for the bond volume cap allocation and for Trinity's construction financing, and December 31, 2028 for completion.
The agreement committed 22 project-based vouchers; the August 28, 2025 amendment raised them to 27, four one-bedrooms at $1,401, 12 two-bedrooms at $1,546 and 11 three-bedrooms at $1,841, and added a Supportive Services Agreement with CORE, INLIVIAN's subsidiary.
WHO BUILDS AND WHO GUARANTEES
Wynnefield Contracting Services builds under a $24,395,237 contract dated October 29, 2025. Trinity Housing Development, its principals John Douglas Hamilton, Joseph Ryan Hamilton and Michael Hamra, and The Vue at Honeywood AM, LLC give the environmental indemnities and the recourse guarantees after stabilization. A former partner in Four Corners Development has sued Trinity and the individual guarantors twice in Greene County, Missouri: a 2022 equity action with no money damages claimed, and a second suit filed January 16, 2026. Remnant Management will manage the property for 6% of gross operating revenue plus $5.50 per unit for bookkeeping, its fee subordinate to the bonds. The developer fee is $1,960,000, $1,430,270 of it deferred.


City Council 3/24/25
Up to $17,000,000 INLIVIAN Multifamily Housing Revenue Bonds | Approved
Council approved INLIVIAN's bonds for The Vue unanimously on March 24, 2025, its second approval of the financing. Mayor Pro Tem Danté Anderson, District 1, pulled both INLIVIAN bond approvals to tell residents that Council approves INLIVIAN's debt but does not run INLIVIAN, then moved approval:

‟It is for a bond not to exceed $17 million, and it's actually within District Two, and the North Carolina Housing Finance Agency has approved a four percent tax credit for that particular project... It's important for the City of Charlotte to have a good working relationship with INLIVIAN.

City Council 1/21/25
2024-115: R-22MF(CD) Site Plan Amendment | Approved
Council approved the site plan amendment on January 21, 2025 with Council Member LaWana Mayfield, At Large, the only vote against. The amendment cuts the permitted seven principal buildings, six shown on the 2021 plan, to three, raises the height limit from 40 feet to 58 feet and adds an amenity building, without adding units. Mayfield could not find the 2021 petition's materials on the City's site and asked whether neighbors should have seen the new plan:

‟Should this not have at least had an opportunity to go back to the community for them to be a part of the discussion again?
Staff answered that the amendment went through community meetings and a public hearing with no opposition.

Zoning Committee 1/7/25
2024-115: R-22MF(CD) Site Plan Amendment | Recommended Approval 7-0
A Zoning Committee member called it an easy recommendation because the unit count does not change: "It's pretty black and white, guys."

City Council 12/16/24
2024-115: R-22MF(CD) Site Plan Amendment | Hearing Held
At the public hearing, Landworks Design Group's Matt Langston explained the redesign for the petitioner: walls and underground storm detention made the 2021 layout too expensive, and fewer buildings make the affordable housing cheaper to build. Council Member Malcolm Graham, District 2, asked whether neighbors had seen the change:

‟Have you already guys had your neighborhood meeting. And any response based on the change of the plan?
One neighbor attended the meeting, and no comment changed the plan. No one spoke against it.

City Council 4/24/23
$3,456,000 Housing Trust Fund Allocation | Approved
Council awarded The Vue $3,456,000 from the Housing Trust Fund on April 24, 2023, one of six developments in a $20,265,000 package, contingent on a tax credit award. The vote was 10 to 1. Council Member Tariq Scott Bokhari, District 6, voted against the whole package, arguing the allocations barely dent the need while roads, sidewalks, stormwater and water piping go unaddressed:

‟I'm a no on that, and I'm a no on all the rest of them as well... Are we making even the slightest dent in it?
Read the Full Analysis: 11/5/26 – 4/24/23 The Vue at Honeywood
Developer: Trinity Housing Development
J. Ryan Hamilton (Presiding Manager/Partner) Phone: (417) 882-1701 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Adam Horton (Chief Development Officer) Phone: (417) 882-1701 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Public Partner: INLIVIAN
Heather Franklin (Interim President and CEO) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Mo McRae (Chief Development Officer) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Capital Partners:
Raymond James Affordable Housing Investments (Tax Credit Investor), Steven J. Kropf (President and Chief Executive Officer) Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Fifth Third Bank (Construction Lender)
Piper Sandler (Underwriter)
AllianceBernstein (Bondholder Representative), Richard Schwam (High Yield Research Analyst, Municipal Credit Research) Phone: (212) 969-1000 LinkedIn
City of Charlotte (Housing Trust Fund Loan)
Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta (Affordable Housing Program Award)
Representatives:
Wynnefield Contracting Services (General Contractor), Skyler George Phone: (910) 280-6699 Email: [email protected]
Halcon Development (Consultant), Traci Dusenbury Tate (Managing Member) Phone: (804) 376-7674 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Urban Trends Real Estate (Consultant), Chris Ogunrinde (CEO) Phone: (704) 612-0971 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Ross Deckard Architects (Architect), James M. Ross, II (President) Phone: (919) 875-0001 Email: [email protected]
Landworks Design Group (Civil Engineer), Matt Langston (Principal & Co-Founder, Landscape Architect) Phone: (704) 841-1604 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Remnant Management (Property Manager), Shannon Pow (Owner and President) Phone: (910) 241-0360 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
McGuireWoods (Bond Counsel), Kristen Kirby (Partner) Phone: (919) 755-6574 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Nixon Peabody (Tax Credit Investor's Counsel), Nathan Bernard (Partner) Phone: (617) 345-1236 Email: [email protected]
Ellinger & Carr (Borrower's Counsel), Steven Carr (Founding Member) Phone: (919) 785-9998 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
The Banks Law Firm (INLIVIAN's Counsel), Sherrod Banks (Shareholder) Phone: (919) 474-9137 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Staff Report: The Vue at Honeywood INLIVIAN Staff Report (August 19, 2025), 2024-115 (January 21, 2025)
Ordinance: 2024-115 Ordinance
Project Plans: The Vue at Honeywood Plans
Presentation: The Vue at Honeywood Housing Trust Fund
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU): The Vue at Honeywood Joint Venture Agreement Amendment (August 28, 2025), The Vue at Honeywood Joint Venture Agreement (May 16, 2025)
Closing Documents: The Vue at Honeywood Limited Offering Memorandum (February 18, 2026)
Deal Scan: The Vue at Honeywood Deal Scan


DISTRICT: 7
Evoke Living at Ballantyne 10615 and 10701 Dixie Hills Dr
South Outer | 4.05 Acres | 60 Units | Built
Deal Tracker 11/5/26 – City Council 6/24/24
Truist Bank Option to Ground Lease and Release of 0.617 Acres from COP Collateral | Approved
Crosland Southeast and the Charlotte nonprofit Freedom Communities have built Evoke Living at Ballantyne's 60 apartments on City land beside the CMPD South Division police station, and INLIVIAN's development company, Horizon Development Properties (HDP), holds its seat for one contribution: 12 project-based vouchers. Under the partners' Joint Venture and Management Services Agreement of March 15, 2023, Freedom holds 60% of the managing member and Crosland's CSE Communities 25%, and the two run it as co-managers; an INLIVIAN subsidiary holds the other 15% solely as a member, and INLIVIAN's development role is limited to the vouchers. For them INLIVIAN takes 15% of the $1,200,000 developer fee, $180,000, and 15% of the managing member's net cash flow. The City keeps the land and leases it for 75 years at $1 a year, and every unit is restricted to households at or below 80% of AMI.
MANAGING MEMBER SPLITS
Term | Freedom Communities | CSE Communities | INLIVIAN |
|---|---|---|---|
Managing member | 60%, co-manager | 25%, co-manager | 15%, member only |
Developer fee, $1,200,000 | 5% | 80% | 15% |
Managing member net cash flow | 70% | 15% | 15% |
CSE also takes a $12,000 asset management fee and a $12,000 guaranty fee each year, each growing 3% a year and paid ahead of the cash flow split. In return, CSE gives every guaranty the lenders and the tax credit investor require, indemnifies Freedom and INLIVIAN if a lender asks either to sign one, and funds predevelopment, repaid at the bond and credit closing; INLIVIAN never refunds predevelopment costs.
The vouchers, two one-bedrooms, seven two-bedrooms and three three-bedrooms, run under a HAP contract of at least 20 years, subject to HUD's approval; if HUD does not provide or renew them, INLIVIAN sells its interest to Freedom for $1. CSE may sell its own interest to Freedom for $1 when the compliance period ends. The partners expect the ownership to carry a full property tax exemption. INLIVIAN awarded the 12 vouchers in December 2023, but the September 2025 financing update still left them out pending HUD's final approval. INLIVIAN's FY2026 budget calls its development company the majority managing member; the signed agreement gives its subsidiary 15% and no management seat.
On June 24, 2024, Council gave Crosland's primary lender, Truist Bank, its own option to ground lease the site on Crosland's terms, a fallback if the lease ends through bankruptcy, foreclosure or early termination before the loan matures. It also asked the trustee on the City's 2021 certificates of participation, which helped pay for the police station, to release 0.617 acres of the station's parcel, the access and parking for the apartments, because Truist required the land free of encumbrances. Both passed unanimously with no discussion, and the financing closed on July 29, 2024.

Deal Tracker
Mecklenburg County issued both buildings' permits on June 25, 2024, the day after Council approved Truist's ground lease option, and the partners closed the financing 34 days later, on July 29, 2024. The City approved the construction plan on November 18, 2024. Both buildings passed their County building finals in September 2026 and hold temporary certificates of occupancy, issued August 27 for Building 1 and October 12 for Building 2; neither has its final certificate. The City's urban forester failed the certificate of occupancy landscape inspection on August 28, 2026, for light poles in tree islands and dead shrubs, and again on October 13 for missing trees, trees planted too high without amended soil, a right-of-way tree to replace and a missing as-built drawing, and kept the hold on Building 2's 27 units. Urban forestry released Building 1 on October 14, City Engineering's hold stays on both buildings, and the next landscape inspections are set for November 28. The City sent the plat dedicating part of Dixie Hills Dr as public right-of-way, filed September 15, back for revisions on October 19. INLIVIAN's final FY2027 plan now counts the 12 project-based vouchers behind INLIVIAN's 15% among its existing vouchers, all 12 planned as leased by year end.

U/ Finance
INLIVIAN's tax-exempt issue, up to $11,500,000, carries the 4% credits. It is a note placed with Truist Bank, whose $10,500,000 construction loan runs at SOFR plus 3.00% for 30 months with a six-month extension; Barings Affordable Housing Mortgage Fund III takes the permanent phase on a 15-year term and 40-year amortization, with final maturity no later than 2042. The State's Local Government Commission approved the issue on March 5, 2024, on cash flows showing 1.45x to 1.67x coverage.
The budget comes to $23,965,884, $399,431 a unit, up from the $22,800,000 the City reviewed in April 2023. Truist Community Capital buys the credits, $1,100,753 a year, at $0.94. Barings' February 2024 terms ran up to $7,063,997 at an estimated 5.95%; the September 2025 sources carry $7,175,000 at 6.02%, interest only for the first three years.
The Housing Trust Fund loan is soft: 1% interest only for 20 years, paid from cash flow after the deferred fee. The CHOIF loan pays interest only for three years after conversion, then hard payments only up to what 1.15x coverage carries. Council allocated $3,100,000 from the Housing Trust Fund on April 24, 2023 and moved up to $1,000,000 more from Evoke Living at Morris Field on February 26, 2024, $4,100,000 in all; the 2025 sources still carry $3,100,000.
GUARANTIES AND WATERFALL
Truist Community Capital's December 2023 terms hold the managing member and the developers jointly to fund any shortfall through stabilization without reimbursement, and test the guarantor each year for $5,000,000 of net worth and $1,250,000 of liquidity. The managing member funds operating deficits up to $382,856, six months of costs, through the year of final closing's fifth anniversary if coverage averages 1.20x. The deferred fee must be paid within 15 years of completion, and the managing member advances it then if cash flow has not. After the deferred fee and the two soft loans, Truist takes 10% of cash flow and the managing member the rest; sale and refinancing proceeds split 90% to the managing member, 10% to Truist. Freedom holds the option to buy the property for 12 months after the compliance period, and the first right of refusal; CSE stands behind it at fair market value.
THE LAND
Date | City Action |
|---|---|
11/15/21 | Rezoned the Providence Rd W tract from R-3 to R-22MF |
2/14/22 | Picked Crosland Southeast from its November 2021 request for proposals, for a long-term ground lease |
6/12/23 | Option and 60-year ground lease at $1 a year; both tracts appraised at $2,350,000 as of April 6, 2023 |
1/8/24 | Option extended to June 30, 2024; lease and affordability terms raised to 75 years for the lender |
The lease covers the 2.75-acre tract where the buildings stand and about 1.3 acres of the police station's parcel for parking and access, 4.05 acres in all. When Council picked Crosland on February 14, 2022, Council Member Reneé Johnson, District 4, asked whether developers given City land at a nominal price should set aside more units for the lowest incomes.


City Council 2/26/24
Housing Trust Fund Reallocation and INLIVIAN Bond Approval | Approved
Council moved up to $1,000,000 of Housing Trust Fund support, saved on Crosland's Evoke Living at Morris Field, to close a gap that cost escalations since the pandemic had opened at Ballantyne, and approved INLIVIAN's bonds on consent. Council Member Reneé Johnson, District 4, asked staff to state the income mix aloud for the public, and Council Member Dimple Ajmera, At Large, welcomed affordable housing in Ballantyne:

‟We are trying to have affordable housing in all parts of our city.

City Council 4/24/23
$3,100,000 Housing Trust Fund Allocation | Approved
Council approved $3,100,000 for Evoke Living at Ballantyne inside a $20,265,000 Housing Trust Fund package for six developments, INLIVIAN's The Vue at Honeywood among them, 10-1 on Council Member LaWana Mayfield's motion. Tariq Scott Bokhari, then the District 6 Council Member, voted against all of it, saying the City should first size its roads, sidewalks, stormwater and water lines:

‟I'm a no on that, and I'm a no on all the rest of them as well. ... Are we making even the slightest dent in it?

City Council 11/15/21
2021-138: R-3 → R-22MF | Approved
Council rezoned the City's Providence Rd W tract from R-3 to R-22MF unanimously on November 15, 2021. Staff recommended approval although the rezoning was inconsistent with the South District Plan, which called for single-family homes at up to 3 units an acre, and the Zoning Committee voted 6-0 for it on October 5. Council Member Ed Driggs, District 7, had deferred the vote a month to explain the plan to neighbors, since a conventional rezoning needs no community meeting; the meeting he held drew one person:

‟As you may remember, colleagues, this is a city owned piece of land and we are rezoning it for a higher density with the intention of putting out an RFP for affordable housing development there.
Read the Full Analysis: 11/5/26 – 11/15/21 Evoke Living at Ballantyne
Developers: Crosland Southeast and Freedom Communities
Tim Sittema (Managing Partner) Phone: (704) 561-5297 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Paul Baalman (Partner, CSE Communities) Phone: (704) 591-2852 Email: [email protected]
Mark Talbot (Chief Economic Impact Officer, Freedom Communities) Phone: (843) 902-7910 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Public Partner: INLIVIAN
Heather Franklin (Interim President and CEO) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Mo McRae (Chief Development Officer) Phone: (704) 336-5183 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
Capital Partners:
Truist Community Capital (Tax Credit Investor)
Truist Bank (Construction Lender)
Barings (Permanent Lender)
LISC Charlotte (CHOIF Loan)
City of Charlotte (Ground Lessor and Housing Trust Fund)
Representatives:
Watts Leaf Architects (Architect), Charles Watts (President) Phone: (704) 376-1200 Email: [email protected] LinkedIn
LandDesign (Civil Engineer), Frank McMahan (Partner) Phone: (704) 333-0325 LinkedIn, Shaun Tooley (Partner) Phone: (704) 333-0325
Opportunities South (Consultant), Dean Edwards (Manager) Phone: (919) 417-0125 Email: [email protected]
Staff Report: 2021-138 Final Staff Analysis (October 18, 2021), 2021-138 Post Hearing Staff Analysis (October 5, 2021), 2021-138 Pre-Hearing Staff Analysis (September 20, 2021)
Ordinance: 2021-138 Ordinance
Memorandum of Understanding (MOU): Evoke Living at Ballantyne Joint Venture Agreement (March 15, 2023)
Term Sheet: Barings Permanent Loan Term Sheet (February 16, 2024), CHOIF II Subordinate Loan Term Sheet (February 6, 2024), Truist Community Capital Term Sheet (December 11, 2023)
Pro Forma: Evoke Living at Ballantyne Pro Forma
Regulatory Agreement: Evoke Living at Ballantyne Section 811 Use Agreement
Deal Scan: Evoke Living at Ballantyne Deal Scan

Thank you for being a part of Ultraground.







